You will like this mascara if you like lengthening mascaras. I would say that this is more of a day mascara because it helps to separate the lashes strand by strand instead of clumping it all together. It helps to lengthen really well. 

Smudging wise, I think it didn't really smudge badly compared to the rest of the mascaras that I have tried. I actually took the photos above upon reaching home. It can be removed easily with cotton pads soaked with eye makeup remover though I normally use cotton buds, its so much easier!